This is the DE Pizza review of Titanic Pizzeria in Milton, Delaware.

This is the DE Pizza Review of Pizza Machine in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware.

At the halfway point, the best pizza in Milton is . . . .

At the halfway point, the best pizza restaurant in Rehoboth is . . . .

Touch of Italy We aren't finished yet. That is the first thing we need to say before handing out any awards. DE Pizza Online has now reviewed almost half of the pizza restaurants on our original list. With summer coming to an end (always a sad thing), we decided it was time for an interim report card. Consider these our halftime scores. There is still plenty of pizza to eat. We also owe an apology to the Delaware Shore communities we haven't reached yet: Dewey Beach, Selbyvil

This is our review of Nicola Pizza, now in Lewes, Delaware.

This is the DE Pizza review of Dough Bar in Milton, Delaware.

This is the DE Pizza review of Crust & Craft in Rehoboth, Delaware.

This is DE Pizza Online's review of Mr. P's Wood-Fired Pizzeria in Lewes.

This is the DE Pizza Review of Pie in Bethany Beach

This is a review of Half Full in Lewes.

This is a review of Ava's Pizzeria & Wine Bar in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware.

This is a review of Gio's Pizza Co. in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware.

This is a review of Mancini's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant.

Review at a Glance: The pizzas: Cheese, Spicy Boy, Carbonara The final rating: 6 out of 8 slices Thinly sliced review: Great service in an empty restaurant, but the pizzas were tasty with maybe the best crunchy thin crusts on the Delaware shore and rich, creamy flavors. There might be a little too much sauce on some of the pizzas, but that sparked some controversy. There were some other disagreements, but we agreed that the prices are pretty high for pizza. Was it worth it? A

Review at a Glance: The pizzas: Cheese, Spicy Boy, Carbonara The final rating: 4 out of 8 slices Thinly sliced review: A place we have affection for, but maybe one that's better as a memory than a meal. Sauce without a lot of flavor or depth. Crusts that stand tall, but not in a good way. A hard, unfoldable Pizza-Hut-like crust. And service that offered dessert before we were halfway through our pizzas. May be we should have had the wings and a lot of beer. Review date: Janua

Review at a Glance: The pizzas: Cheese, pepperoni The final rating: 4 out of 8 slices Thinly sliced review: Despite a lot of memories of this venerable pizza institution, the pizza is somewhere between immemorable and decidedly mediocre --- the kind of pizza you serve at a birthday party for little kids. Sauce applied with a hose and "pizza cheese" (whatever that is) make for a liquidy topping on top of largely flavorless crust with grocery-store pepperoni on top. The signatu

Review at a Glance: The pizzas: Cheese, puttanesca The final rating: 5 out of 8 slices Thinly sliced review: The first public pizza fistfight on DE Pizza Online. Sharp disagreement over, well, almost everything. The sauce was thin and the cheese was gorcery-store quslity, but we disagreed about the crust and the veggie toppings on one pizza. Maybe we agreed about the cheese pizza. But should pizza spark a disagreement or a celebration? Review date: January 18, 2026 Rating: Fi