Touch of Italy We aren't finished yet. That is the first thing we need to say before handing out any awards. DE Pizza Online has now reviewed almost half of the pizza restaurants on our original list. With summer coming to an end (always a sad thing), we decided it was time for an interim report card. Consider these our halftime scores. There is still plenty of pizza to eat. We also owe an apology to the Delaware Shore communities we haven't reached yet: Dewey Beach, Selbyvil

This is our review of Nicola Pizza, now in Lewes, Delaware.

This is DE Pizza Online's review of Mr. P's Wood-Fired Pizzeria in Lewes.

This is a review of Half Full in Lewes.

Review at a Glance: The pizzas: Cheese, pepperoni The final rating: 8 out of 8 slices Thinly sliced review: Creamy, salty fresh mozzarella. Sauce that's a little sweet, flavorful, and very bright. Crust that's crispy, chewy, tasty, and salty. Topped by elite pepperoni slices. All served quickly by a favorite server in a setting that evokes a lot of personal memories. Review date: January 18, 2026 Rating: Final Composite Score: 7.5 out of 8 slices ("rounded" up to 8 out of 8 s